Cookbook dependencies doc

silviu_dicu · February 27, 2014, 6:32pm

Hi,

Could somebody point to a document describing how the cookbook dependencies are calculated ?

I found for attributes http://docs.opscode.com/chef_overview_attributes.html but not sure if apply for cookbook version constraints.

thanks!

silviu

Mike · February 27, 2014, 7:50pm

Did you read http://docs.opscode.com/essentials_cookbook_versions.html ?

Best,
-M

On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 1:32 PM, Silviu Dicu silviudicu@gmail.com wrote:

Hi,

Could somebody point to a document describing how the cookbook
dependencies are calculated ?

I found for attributes
About Attributes but not sure if
apply for cookbook version constraints.

thanks!

silviu

silviu_dicu · February 28, 2014, 12:17am

Hi,

I was looking for a document that explains what is the merging order of the
dependencies and who will win in the end
Take a situation like this

Node run config
{
"name": "test-constraints",
"chef_environment": "test",
"normal": {
},
"run_list": [
"recipe[a]"
]
}

$ grep depends cookbooks/a/metadata.rb
depends "b"
depends "tech", "= 0.3.0"

$ tail -1 cookbooks/a/recipes/default.rb
include_recipe "b"

$ grep depends cookbooks/b/metadata.rb
depends "tech", "= 0.1.0"

$ tail -1 cookbooks/b/recipes/default.rb
include_recipe "tech"

$ grep tech environments/test.json
"tech": "= 0.2.0"

This runs w/o problems.
But if I change environment to = 0.1.0 will do this

[2014-02-28T00:07:36+00:00] INFO: HTTP Request Returned 412 Precondition
Failed: {"message"=>"Unable to solve constraints, the following solutions
were attempted \n\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to
constraint on tech\n (a = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.2.0)\n Unable to
satisfy goal constraint a due to constraints on tech\n (a = 0.2.0)
-> (tech = 0.3.0)\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (b = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.1.0)\n",
"unsatisfiable_run_list_item"=>["a"], "non_existent_cookbooks"=>,
"most_constrained_cookbooks"=>["(tech = 0.2.0)"]}

If I change environment to = 0.3.0

[2014-02-28T00:13:08+00:00] INFO: HTTP Request Returned 412 Precondition
Failed: {"message"=>"Unable to solve constraints, the following solutions
were attempted \n\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to
constraint on tech\n (a = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.2.0)\n Unable to
satisfy goal constraint a due to constraints on tech\n (a = 0.2.0)
-> (tech = 0.3.0)\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (b = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.1.0)\n",
"unsatisfiable_run_list_item"=>["a"], "non_existent_cookbooks"=>,
"most_constrained_cookbooks"=>["(tech = 0.2.0)"]}

$ knife cookbook show tech
tech 0.3.0 0.2.0 0.1.0

thanks!

-silviu

Best,
-M

On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 1:32 PM, Silviu Dicu silviudicu@gmail.com wrote:

Hi,

Could somebody point to a document describing how the cookbook
dependencies are calculated ?

I found for attributes
About Attributes but not sure if
apply for cookbook version constraints.

thanks!

silviu

coderanger · February 28, 2014, 12:26am

There is no winner per se, all constraints must be satisfied. You will have to fix your dependencies for this to have a valid solution.

--Noah

On Feb 27, 2014, at 4:17 PM, Silviu Dicu silviudicu@gmail.com wrote:

Hi,

I was looking for a document that explains what is the merging order of the dependencies and who will win in the end
Take a situation like this

Node run config
{
"name": "test-constraints",
"chef_environment": "test",
"normal": {
},
"run_list": [
"recipe[a]"
]
}

$ grep depends cookbooks/a/metadata.rb
depends "b"
depends "tech", "= 0.3.0"

$ tail -1 cookbooks/a/recipes/default.rb
include_recipe "b"

$ grep depends cookbooks/b/metadata.rb
depends "tech", "= 0.1.0"

$ tail -1 cookbooks/b/recipes/default.rb
include_recipe "tech"

$ grep tech environments/test.json
"tech": "= 0.2.0"

This runs w/o problems.
But if I change environment to = 0.1.0 will do this

[2014-02-28T00:07:36+00:00] INFO: HTTP Request Returned 412 Precondition Failed: {"message"=>"Unable to solve constraints, the following solutions were attempted \n\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to constraint on tech\n (a = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.2.0)\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to constraints on tech\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (tech = 0.3.0)\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (b = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.1.0)\n", "unsatisfiable_run_list_item"=>["a"], "non_existent_cookbooks"=>, "most_constrained_cookbooks"=>["(tech = 0.2.0)"]}

If I change environment to = 0.3.0

[2014-02-28T00:13:08+00:00] INFO: HTTP Request Returned 412 Precondition Failed: {"message"=>"Unable to solve constraints, the following solutions were attempted \n\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to constraint on tech\n (a = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.2.0)\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to constraints on tech\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (tech = 0.3.0)\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (b = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.1.0)\n", "unsatisfiable_run_list_item"=>["a"], "non_existent_cookbooks"=>, "most_constrained_cookbooks"=>["(tech = 0.2.0)"]}

$ knife cookbook show tech
tech 0.3.0 0.2.0 0.1.0

thanks!

-silviu

Best,
-M

On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 1:32 PM, Silviu Dicu silviudicu@gmail.com wrote:
Hi,

Could somebody point to a document describing how the cookbook dependencies are calculated ?

I found for attributes About Attributes but not sure if apply for cookbook version constraints.

thanks!

silviu

silviu_dicu · March 1, 2014, 2:44am

Hi Noah,

Thanks for your answer, as I said I was looking to find a document that
explains
how the decision is taken, the closest I found as a 'doc' is

github.com

chef-boneyard/depsolver/blob/master/src/depsolver.erl#L23


      
          %% Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing,
          %% software distributed under the License is distributed on an
          %% "AS IS" BASIS, WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY
          %% KIND, either express or implied.  See the License for the
          %% specific language governing permissions and limitations
          %% under the License.
          %%
          %% @author Eric Merritt <ericbmerritt@gmail.com>
          %%
          %%%-------------------------------------------------------------------
          %%% @doc
          %%% This is a dependency constraint solver. You add your 'world' to the
          %%% solver. That is the packages that exist, their versions and their
          %%% dependencies. Then give the system a set of targets and ask it to solve.
          %%%
          %%%  Lets say our world looks as follows
          %%%
          %%%      app1 that has versions "0.1"
          %%%        depends on app3 any version greater then "0.2"
          %%%       "0.2" with no dependencies
          %%%       "0.3" with no dependencies

-silviu

On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 7:26 PM, Noah Kantrowitz noah@coderanger.netwrote:

There is no winner per se, all constraints must be satisfied. You will
have to fix your dependencies for this to have a valid solution.

--Noah

On Feb 27, 2014, at 4:17 PM, Silviu Dicu silviudicu@gmail.com wrote:

Hi,

I was looking for a document that explains what is the merging order of
the dependencies and who will win in the end
Take a situation like this

Node run config
{
"name": "test-constraints",
"chef_environment": "test",
"normal": {
},
"run_list": [
"recipe[a]"
]
}

$ grep depends cookbooks/a/metadata.rb
depends "b"
depends "tech", "= 0.3.0"

$ tail -1 cookbooks/a/recipes/default.rb
include_recipe "b"

$ grep depends cookbooks/b/metadata.rb
depends "tech", "= 0.1.0"

$ tail -1 cookbooks/b/recipes/default.rb
include_recipe "tech"

$ grep tech environments/test.json
"tech": "= 0.2.0"

This runs w/o problems.
But if I change environment to = 0.1.0 will do this

[2014-02-28T00:07:36+00:00] INFO: HTTP Request Returned 412 Precondition
Failed: {"message"=>"Unable to solve constraints, the following solutions
were attempted \n\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to
constraint on tech\n (a = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.2.0)\n Unable to
satisfy goal constraint a due to constraints on tech\n (a = 0.2.0)
-> (tech = 0.3.0)\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (b = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.1.0)\n",
"unsatisfiable_run_list_item"=>["a"], "non_existent_cookbooks"=>,
"most_constrained_cookbooks"=>["(tech = 0.2.0)"]}

If I change environment to = 0.3.0

[2014-02-28T00:13:08+00:00] INFO: HTTP Request Returned 412 Precondition
Failed: {"message"=>"Unable to solve constraints, the following solutions
were attempted \n\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to
constraint on tech\n (a = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.2.0)\n Unable to
satisfy goal constraint a due to constraints on tech\n (a = 0.2.0)
-> (tech = 0.3.0)\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (b = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.1.0)\n",
"unsatisfiable_run_list_item"=>["a"], "non_existent_cookbooks"=>,
"most_constrained_cookbooks"=>["(tech = 0.2.0)"]}

$ knife cookbook show tech
tech 0.3.0 0.2.0 0.1.0

thanks!

-silviu

Best,
-M

On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 1:32 PM, Silviu Dicu silviudicu@gmail.com
wrote:
Hi,

Could somebody point to a document describing how the cookbook
dependencies are calculated ?

I found for attributes
About Attributes but not sure if
apply for cookbook version constraints.

thanks!

silviu

coderanger · March 1, 2014, 2:48am

I wouldn't count on that behavior. Erchef will switching back the Ruby (gecode) depsolver soon, and Berkshelf as its own based on the Solve gem

--Noah

On Feb 28, 2014, at 6:44 PM, Silviu Dicu silviudicu@gmail.com wrote:

Hi Noah,

Thanks for your answer, as I said I was looking to find a document that explains
how the decision is taken, the closest I found as a 'doc' is https://github.com/opscode/depsolver/blob/master/src/depsolver.erl#L23

-silviu

On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 7:26 PM, Noah Kantrowitz noah@coderanger.net wrote:
There is no winner per se, all constraints must be satisfied. You will have to fix your dependencies for this to have a valid solution.

--Noah

On Feb 27, 2014, at 4:17 PM, Silviu Dicu silviudicu@gmail.com wrote:

Hi,

I was looking for a document that explains what is the merging order of the dependencies and who will win in the end
Take a situation like this

Node run config
{
"name": "test-constraints",
"chef_environment": "test",
"normal": {
},
"run_list": [
"recipe[a]"
]
}

$ grep depends cookbooks/a/metadata.rb
depends "b"
depends "tech", "= 0.3.0"

$ tail -1 cookbooks/a/recipes/default.rb
include_recipe "b"

$ grep depends cookbooks/b/metadata.rb
depends "tech", "= 0.1.0"

$ tail -1 cookbooks/b/recipes/default.rb
include_recipe "tech"

$ grep tech environments/test.json
"tech": "= 0.2.0"

This runs w/o problems.
But if I change environment to = 0.1.0 will do this

[2014-02-28T00:07:36+00:00] INFO: HTTP Request Returned 412 Precondition Failed: {"message"=>"Unable to solve constraints, the following solutions were attempted \n\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to constraint on tech\n (a = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.2.0)\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to constraints on tech\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (tech = 0.3.0)\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (b = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.1.0)\n", "unsatisfiable_run_list_item"=>["a"], "non_existent_cookbooks"=>, "most_constrained_cookbooks"=>["(tech = 0.2.0)"]}

If I change environment to = 0.3.0

[2014-02-28T00:13:08+00:00] INFO: HTTP Request Returned 412 Precondition Failed: {"message"=>"Unable to solve constraints, the following solutions were attempted \n\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to constraint on tech\n (a = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.2.0)\n Unable to satisfy goal constraint a due to constraints on tech\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (tech = 0.3.0)\n (a = 0.2.0) -> (b = 0.1.0) -> (tech = 0.1.0)\n", "unsatisfiable_run_list_item"=>["a"], "non_existent_cookbooks"=>, "most_constrained_cookbooks"=>["(tech = 0.2.0)"]}

$ knife cookbook show tech
tech 0.3.0 0.2.0 0.1.0

thanks!

-silviu

Best,
-M

On Thu, Feb 27, 2014 at 1:32 PM, Silviu Dicu silviudicu@gmail.com wrote:
Hi,

Could somebody point to a document describing how the cookbook dependencies are calculated ?

I found for attributes About Attributes but not sure if apply for cookbook version constraints.

thanks!

silviu

Lamont_Granquist_OLD · March 1, 2014, 5:21am

On Fri Feb 28 18:48:05 2014, Noah Kantrowitz wrote:

I wouldn't count on that behavior. Erchef will switching back the Ruby (gecode) depsolver soon, and Berkshelf as its own based on the Solve gem

Berkshelf will be switching to gecode as well. Dan has been working on
getting gecode to compile under windows.

coderanger · March 1, 2014, 5:27am

On Feb 28, 2014, at 9:21 PM, Lamont Granquist lamont@opscode.com wrote:

On Fri Feb 28 18:48:05 2014, Noah Kantrowitz wrote:

I wouldn't count on that behavior. Erchef will switching back the Ruby (gecode) depsolver soon, and Berkshelf as its own based on the Solve gem

Berkshelf will be switching to gecode as well. Dan has been working on getting gecode to compile under windows.

To those that haven't had the pleasure of solver inconsistencies this is is an improvement roughly on par with "we are replacing your Geo Metro with a Model S".

--Noah

Lamont_Granquist_OLD · March 1, 2014, 5:47am

On Fri Feb 28 21:27:22 2014, Noah Kantrowitz wrote:

On Feb 28, 2014, at 9:21 PM, Lamont Granquist lamont@opscode.com wrote:

On Fri Feb 28 18:48:05 2014, Noah Kantrowitz wrote:

I wouldn't count on that behavior. Erchef will switching back the Ruby (gecode) depsolver soon, and Berkshelf as its own based on the Solve gem

Berkshelf will be switching to gecode as well. Dan has been working on getting gecode to compile under windows.

To those that haven't had the pleasure of solver inconsistencies this is is an improvement roughly on par with "we are replacing your Geo Metro with a Model S".

--Noah

Well, a Model S that takes 10 minutes to compile every time you refuel
it...

Ionut_Artarisi · March 3, 2014, 10:41am

On 27.2.2014 19:32, Silviu Dicu wrote:

Hi,

Could somebody point to a document describing how the cookbook dependencies are calculated ?

I found for attributes About Attributes but not sure if apply for cookbook version constraints.

thanks!

silviu

Hey Silviu,

FWIW, I also had problems figuring out a cookbook's full dependency list
and sent a patch to have chef list the full dependency branch when it
fails to find a cookbook's dependencies at runtime:
https://tickets.opscode.com/browse/CHEF-5065

This might help you or others.

-Ionuț

Milind_Patil · March 3, 2014, 1:48pm

May I know how to put new problem for discussion on this forum?

-----Original Message-----
From: Ionuț Arțăriși [mailto:iartarisi@suse.cz]
Sent: Monday, March 3, 2014 4:12 PM
To: chef@lists.opscode.com
Subject: [chef] Re: Cookbook dependencies doc

On 27.2.2014 19:32, Silviu Dicu wrote:

Hi,

Could somebody point to a document describing how the cookbook dependencies are calculated ?

I found for attributes About Attributes but not sure if apply for cookbook version constraints.

thanks!

silviu

Hey Silviu,

FWIW, I also had problems figuring out a cookbook's full dependency list and sent a patch to have chef list the full dependency branch when it fails to find a cookbook's dependencies at runtime:
https://tickets.opscode.com/browse/CHEF-5065

This might help you or others.

-Ionuț

DISCLAIMER

This e-mail may contain privileged and confidential information which is the property of Persistent Systems Ltd. It is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, you are not authorized to read, retain, copy, print, distribute or use this message. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the sender and delete all copies of this message. Persistent Systems Ltd. does not accept any liability for virus infected mails.

coderanger · March 3, 2014, 6:50pm

Not entirely sure what you mean. If you think you've found a bug or error in Chef you can just file a ticket on tickets.opscode.com. If you just have a question, you can email this list.

--Noah

On Mar 3, 2014, at 5:48 AM, Milind Patil milind_patil1@persistent.co.in wrote:

May I know how to put new problem for discussion on this forum?

-----Original Message-----
From: Ionuț Arțăriși [mailto:iartarisi@suse.cz]
Sent: Monday, March 3, 2014 4:12 PM
To: chef@lists.opscode.com
Subject: [chef] Re: Cookbook dependencies doc

On 27.2.2014 19:32, Silviu Dicu wrote:

Hi,

Could somebody point to a document describing how the cookbook dependencies are calculated ?

I found for attributes About Attributes but not sure if apply for cookbook version constraints.

thanks!

silviu

Hey Silviu,

FWIW, I also had problems figuring out a cookbook's full dependency list and sent a patch to have chef list the full dependency branch when it fails to find a cookbook's dependencies at runtime:
https://tickets.opscode.com/browse/CHEF-5065

This might help you or others.

-Ionuț

DISCLAIMER

This e-mail may contain privileged and confidential information which is the property of Persistent Systems Ltd. It is intended only for the use of the individual or entity to which it is addressed. If you are not the intended recipient, you are not authorized to read, retain, copy, print, distribute or use this message. If you have received this communication in error, please notify the sender and delete all copies of this message. Persistent Systems Ltd. does not accept any liability for virus infected mails.

Topic		Replies	Views
Vesion Contraints Chef Infra (archive)	4	353	April 5, 2014
Cookbook Dependency Version Question Chef Infra (archive)	4	488	May 16, 2013
Opinions on Cookbook version contraints - environment or cookbook Chef Infra (archive)	4	1050	April 22, 2016
Managing cookbok dependency versions on environments vs metadata Chef Infra (archive)	0	344	October 16, 2018
Cookbook version dependency selection on chef server Chef Infra (archive)	2	407	November 11, 2014

Cookbook dependencies doc

DISCLAIMER

DISCLAIMER

Related Topics