I am traveling at the moment, and I am on GMT+8, so I may reply to
this and other threads with quite a bit of latency…
On Wed, Apr 25, 2012 at 10:22 AM, Daniel Cukier firstname.lastname@example.org wrote:
Bryan, I’ve looked to this refactor, but actually I did not find a good
documentation of how to use it.
Interesting. The documentation is one of the areas I am looking for feedback on.
If you can spare a few minutes, can you elaborate on what you find
unclear in the documentation? Here or private email.
I guess a “how to convert from the old version” tutorial, as you
suggest, would be helpful.
From what I’ve understood, I need to create a cookbook for my_app and add
the application code block to the default.rb of my cookbook. Is it correct?
If it is so, then it is worse than before, when all I needed to do was
create a data_bag, put some configuration there and create a my_app role
with the application default recipe in its run_list.
To be clear: I don’t think removal of the data bag was a goal of the
project, it’s more of a side casualty.
Data bags are not very expressive; while it was pretty easy to get
started, people with more advanced use cases kept bumping into
limitations. For example, some attributes were per-environment, some
Since the new DSL is more complete and powerful than the old recipe,
it would be quite hard to create a purely data bag-driven mode that is
useful and generic for everybody.
On the other hand, it’s pretty easy to roll your own, as Joshua has
Nobody knows what you need better than you, so if you’d rather use a
data bag I suggest you look into that approach.
Another thing is: with this new refactor, do I still need to add the
application recipe to the node run_list?
If your cookbook correctly depends on application and
application_rails (if it’s a Rails app), you don’t need to explicitly
include the application cookbook.
Moreover, the application::default recipe (and the stack-specific
ones) will be deprecated. Once you are done converting all your apps
to the “new style”, you should remove that recipe from the run_list.
We will be keeping backward compatibility, with a deprecation warning,
for about 3 months.